First, there were the Santa days. To be honest, I believed in Santa for a VERY short amount of time...and during that short time, the idea of him scared me more than anything. One of my earliest memories is staying up on Christmas Eve--hearing a faint thumping from the family room, feeling sure it was Santa, creeping downstairs but then being too petrified to turn the corner and peek. (In retrospect, the thumping was probably my dad banging his leg on a table or something.) Once I entered elementary school, I secretly knew Santa didn't exist, but I pretended to believe in him anyway, so that I'd get an extra present from my parents. :) When my sister got to be a toddler, I took up the role of Santa, picking out special surprise presents, encouraging her to write a note to Santa and then writing a reply (complete with Rudolph's paw print), pretending to eat the cookies, knocking down a few things near the fireplace to add to the authenticity of Santa's visit, and so on. Being Santa was my favorite part of the holidays.
When my sister became a fifth grader, I figured she was too old to believe in Santa. It was for her own good, otherwise she might be teased at school. Besides, the previous year, I'd sort of messed things up...being way too excited about a new stereo we'd bought for her present from Santa, I made a mad dash for the living room while carrying the gigantic wrapped gift. It was so big that it obstructed my vision, and just as she glanced over from the next room, I accidentally ran into a wall and fell over. The next day she still acted surprised and overjoyed when she unwrapped the stereo...but I'm pretty sure she'd figured things out by then.
Then came the time of creative family gifts. I'm not sure how it started, but my sister and I started making a big deal out of our parents' birthdays. The first big surprise was probably when I gave my mom a giant birthday card one year. It was at least half her height and took me several days to make. For my dad's birthday, my sister had the idea of doing a puppet show. We made hand puppets out of paper bags, one puppet representing each member of the family, and we wrote a skit of daily scenes from our lives that highlighted my dad's idiosyncrasies and funny moments. Then we "performed" the puppet show for him on his birthday, from behind the couch of the living room. I don't know if my dad actually enjoyed it, but Mei and I had a LOT of fun doing it. Thus was born the tradition of performances on our parents' birthdays and Christmas. One year, we took a bunch of my dad's favorite songs, wrote a medley version for piano and guitar/violin, and changed the lyrics so that they were about him. Another year, my dad, sister, and I performed a skit about my mom--my dad played the roles of my sister and me, my sister played my dad, and I played my mom. My mom still says that skit is one of her all-time favorite memories.
But eventually, this got old. It was so much fun, but a) I ran out of ideas (the only thing left was to do a musical, and that was WAY too complicated...), b) I left for college and only came home a few days before Christmas, and c) I ended up being the only one who did most of the work...my sister lounged around and goofed off while I wracked my brain over various lyrics or lines or melodies. It started feeling like an obligation. So we stopped doing performances and just gave normal presents, but still made every effort to keep everything a secret. On Christmas morning we'd still be surprised by what we found under the tree, and in the days leading up to Christmas, we'd still be inwardly smiling, excited to see the looks on the others' faces when they saw what we'd gotten them.
Now, we have evolved to the most practical form of gift-giving. A couple weeks before Christmas, we make public announcements of the items we want. Then, we decide who will get what for whom. This year, my dad wants a baseball cap that he can fit in his pocket. My mom wants a coffee machine. I want a NY Times crossword calendar, and my sister wants the Harry Potter 7 DVD (Part 2). We decided that, since everyone only wants one thing, we'd each receive only one collective present from the family this year. I felt like this was too boring, so I said each person could opt for a "surprise" present if they wanted. Then, my mom piped up that actually, she already bought herself the coffee machine, so we don't need to get her anything at all.
On practical terms, until you're financially independent, you and your family basically share your money in one big pool, and getting your parents a gift is sort of the monetary equivalent of them buying themselves a gift. And, as Sheldon on the Big Bang Theory puts it, when you give someone a present, you are also giving an obligation. The receiver of the present then has to reciprocate with a present to you, and thus ensues a tiresome and stressful exchange until one party dies, leaving the other party one present richer. So, instead of this tiresome business of buying presents and keeping secrets, why don't we just each go out and get something we want for ourselves, for Christmas? Apparently, that is exactly what people in China do--they don't celebrate Christmas, probably don't even know what Christmas is really about, but they do have a holiday season, which they celebrate by shopping...not for one another, but for themselves.
I can't really say that this sort of practicality is greedy, nor can I say I'm sad that my family has become steadily less creative...from Rudolph paw prints to self-bought coffee machines, from home-made songs and skits to requested gifts we know we'll receive. I mean, I do miss the good old days, and I miss exercising my creative juices and seeing the surprised delight on my family's faces. But the good thing is, we evolved together; doing a puppet show or forging a note from Santa would just seem silly and forced for all of us, now. I imagine the great thing about being parents is being able to "grow up" all over again, with your kids. I think my parents had a great and giddy time doing all those fun things with my sister and me when we were young...and now we're all growing up, my sister and I for the first time, and my parents for a second time. Maybe we'll go through the cycle again when there's a new generation. Meanwhile, I'm eagerly awaiting a predictable but equally satisfying Christmas, and just as thankful as usual to be with my family for the holidays, celebrating the birth of Christ together. :)